Letters to the Editor: Details emerge about ToonKriticY2K's past actions by

The following post contains an unedited letter sent to the Horse News staff, from a reader named Massiker Mollie in response to recently publicized information regarding the alleged actions of ToonKriticY2K. The views and information provided are not necessarily those of Horse News, and have not been independently verified.  If you have a message to share, send it to horsenewsmlp@gmail.com 



In the hours since the information and details about the actions of ToonKriticY2K were revealed to the public, there have been several accounts and comments from others who claim to have been involved with him, attesting to his alleged behavior in the past. Among them is a recount of an experience dubbed "Abby's Story", which is given by Youtube user Cavatina, involving a personal friend. 



Another comes in the form of a Youtube comment on Vida's video outlining the event by a user named PurpleRoselyn who claims their friend had been "groped by him at a con". It is unclear at this time how many others will come forward with their own accounts in the coming days, but there is one account that was sent to us from a Youtube user named Massiker Mollie who had been in a "rocky relationship" with ToonKritic for several years.

Below, is her unedited letter (only altered spacing for formatting purposes).

"My experiences with ToonKritic have been a very rocky relationship to say the least. Both of us got along great in September of 2014 and from then till summer of 2015 have been a rocky relationship. At the time of a few months into 2015 he and I chatted on skype on occasions, but it wasn't until I was aware of how...sleazy he was during the late spring early summer of 2015.
I even remember this to this day: I was in a livestream with Toon, Thespio, Jasper Pie, his old buddy Flamez, Eliyora, and Aeon and Eli was playing FFVII and we were all goofing off in the stream, and it wasn't until during that stream that things between me and Toon got...weird..
.
During the stream, we were joking around about sex talk and normal convos, and as a joke, I shook my fully clothed ass at the camera, everyone cracked up, they found it funny, the Toon shook his ass at the stream (clothed as well) and we were laughing as well. It wasn't till midway in the stream that I got private PMs from Toon complimenting on hos nice my ass looked, and even said "I heard from a sourse that you like me or something?", which  did at the time. And I told him that while it was true, I was being respectful of the fact he was in a relationship with Eli. Then he pulls me into a private call and was saying that he loved Kat but he wasn't getting the sex he wanted so he had asked if I was going to BC that year and if so... did me and him want to have sex. I blindingly said sure, but I wanted to be respectful that I didn't want him and Eli to break up. So in call, he had asked to see what I looked like on camera, the he asked to see what I looked like naked, and I'll admit, it wasn't smart at the time... that was when now I noticed it was a red flag that was doing that while in a relationship.  looking on it now I wish I hadn't done so' 
This continued were we would occasionally do ERPs every so often and I was added into the Domain for a while, and introduced me to his friends. During that time I was in there he had mentioned how he was insanely attracted to me, and had said what he wanted to do with me in the hotel room at cons, and would persist on the idea of us being together. It wasn't until he and Eli broke up that soon my time in the Domain was up. He chucked me out and ended up accusing me of his and Eli's breakup. When I tried to explain my side of it, he wouldn't listen. It wasn't till after BC 2015 he messages me out of the blue and apologized for how he acted and asked if we could start over, which I said yes. And from then in private PMs he and did ERPs every now and then, him occasionally asking for pics of me naked, with bra and panties, and one with stockings.  I sent him those and he sent me a few pics of himself nakedn and we did voice calls of us naked... after awhile, he was dating his old friend Schane and he said that we needed to break it off. And then afterwards (pastel, twist, and season know this) that started the hate boner of me and toon going back and forth of us hating each other
I was even in the skype call where he had asked Fallenwish to pay for her coming to Ciderfest a few years ago. And I was against him when he had commited fraud for stealing $700 from Fallen 
It wasn't until around BC 2016 that me and toon were cool, but then it got bad when he called me a "psycho cyberstalker" that wanted to get in his pants, and had his friends, who I was cool with at the time, turn on me and point me out for stalking and harassing him at cons. 
After that around September of 2016 that we made up and were on good terms and were able to put the issues behind us. He and I went into our usual ERP convos, and he had said again how attracted he was of me, what he would do to me in his bedroom, and asked if I was attending whinnycity ponycon with him last year. I ended up going to the con, that's where I met Watchful, Razor Reviews, and Toons BF at the time Mo. AT the time, you guys knew I was with my BF at the time Seth, so both of us were in relationships but Toon considered us "friends with benefits" at the time. 
I'm not proud for what I did at whinnycity at the time... I completely regret it because Seth was better... but Toon had sex with me at whinnycity while under his BF's nose, and his bf never caught wind of it at all. At the time that happened I enjoyed it, but looking on it now... I regret doing so with him. After that he and I occasionally chatted and did more ERPs and had asked if I wanted to have sex with him again at BC last year. And he ended up snubbing me during the time. And while that was happening I was full of guilt because this was when I had broken up with Seth because I felt "something was in the way" (which was toon, weaseling his way into mine and seth's relationship) and I had hoped BC would be fun to hang out with everyone, and have a great weekend. For those that were at BC, I'm sure y'all noticed how irritable and snappy I was at you guys, and it was due to me wanting to spend time with Toon, but not having the chance because we were always busy. It wasn't till the last day of the con, Toon came into my hotel room where me and my roomies were chilling out, and he had apologized for not spending time with me.  I forgave him for that then we said our goodbyes and we left 
After BC that's when things took a turn for the worst. After BC, I had confided in Fallen that I did want to try dating him, and that she was encouraging me to, and the rest of you guys were throwing the redflags of saying "don't do this" "he's bad news" and I didn't listen because I was blinded by lust I had for him. I was going to go to Ciderfest for my bday and he had pmed me if I was going, what I wanted to do for my birthday while there, and he wanted to "make up" for not spending time with me at BC. But then the allegations of me being a "cyberstalker" came up again and had caused him to back off and ditch me. He said he was not interested and he would be frowned upon by his friends in the Domain if he dated me. That's where the final straw hit for me because that was when I was questioning all his motives, whe he was doing that to me, and keep in mind guys, I was his "rebound girl": his puppet, someone to fall back on when his relationships failed. That was all I was to him for 4 years I was his main "side-chick" for his failed relationships. He got rid of me and disposed of me like I was a fucking tissue 
I have helped him with more situations than one. I was his meatshield, like how Pastel was to Fallen. I protected him from getting hit, I helped him with his funds on his family car, grandpa's surgery, his house bills, I helped his depression and anxiety, and he had the nerve, the GODDAMN GALL to cast me aside and not even care about what I did to help him
And it had me thinking that he never cared about any of the people he got with. He never liked any of them. He was looking for a quick thrill, and once that happened he threw them away like yesterday's garbage. 
I've seen his true colors before, but now seeing this... it honestly makes me wonder why I was attracted to a weaseling, conniving, piece of shit in the first place...He was a person I considered my friend. I was one of his regular Patron on his Patreon, and was actually a descent guy back in 2015. But after that, he completely changed
I tried to reason with him on some stuff he did wrong and I got through to him once ort twice, but he didn't want to hear my advice on it this time" - Massiker Mollie

Comments (69)

  1. dam this guy has problems he really needs to see some pro help

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hotmail / outlook is the oldest and most robust mail service. Your Hotmail account is your Microsoft account at the same time.
      hotmail sign up
      hotmail login

      Delete
  2. Toon is definitely a manipulative and abusive scum-bag, but not all this shit is on him. My sympathies to these girls, but many were willing victims. Obviously the ones groped were sexually assaulted and it's hard to put any blame on the more naive and younger teens that fell for his...charms, but others Massiker were just horny sluts that went along and even contributed to Toon's shenanigans.

    There were far too many in the community and his group of friends that were well aware of Toon's sexual decency and manipulative behavior, but either ignored it or helped downplay just how bad he was. It's only now, being caught doing this shit with a teenager they call him out and distance themselves.

    People knew of his predatory behavior and did nothing to stop it and in my eyes that means the analysis community has a lot to answer for.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. And I can almost guarantee you they never will. They'll try and sweep it under theach rug as best as they can and act as though it never happened. There won't be mass apologies for their errors, as that would damage their reputation in the fandom as well as their perceived "YouTube careers".

      Delete
    2. >but many were willing victims.
      Thank you. Someone who knows that the girls are not 100% angels who "could do no such thing!" They were partly to blame for all this shit for going along with Toon's fucked up actions. Spoiled brats who got no parents that tells them to not talk to creepy strangers on the internet. Losers who got no jobs and apparently doesn't know what masturbation is to prevent themselves from being blinded by lust. Etcete-fucking-ra.


      The reiterate, I'm not defending Toon. He even committed other crimes like drugs and violence and I'd say he well deserved that jail time. But believe me when I say, both sides gets blame. Even just by a little bit.

      Delete
    3. Honestly there really isn't a way to draw the line as to who was willing and who got suckered into the codependency nature of an abusive relationship like that. If anything it could imply the backgrounds of those victims. No parental guidance and no one to turn to leads down such paths.

      Delete
    4. >willing victims
      Of course they're "willing victims" when they're 14 fucking years old, they don't know any better. I don't think i've ever come across a 14-year old who i'm confident would shy away from what Toon has manipulated underage grills into doing now. They're not willing, they're unknowing.

      Delete
    5. Buuuuuuuulllshit. Don't treat these 14 year olds as if they're fucking infants who didn't know any better. They know exactly what the fuck is going on. 9 year olds who gets laptops search up anime porn on YouTube. I fixed computers and I've seen fucked up shit kids do on their computers. Go live in a 3rd world country and you'll see a WHOLE NEW culture of teenagers. I know, cause I live there myself.

      See http://i.4cdn.org/mlp/1517030641651.png

      Delete
    6. so true i seen 14 yr olds sleep with their teachers fake innocent so they dont get in trouble. hell when i was 14 i already knew about porn. what 14 yr old does not know what they are doing

      Delete
    7. I still think you guys are looking at it in the wrong direction. The underlying problem of an abusive relationship makes the willingness much harder to gauge than age or what they're doing regularly on the Internet.

      Delete
    8. >Don't treat these 14 year olds as if they're fucking infants who didn't know any better.

      missingthewholepoint.txt

      Delete
    9. >Teens have porn on their computer so they can not be taken advantage off.
      Epic meme my dude XD
      But seriously, kys, especially for the victim blaming. Of his victims, only massiker is a piece of shit too.

      Delete
  3. I know it's nowhere near as bad. But the guy is also a poser to a degree. When I first met him at ponyville Ciderfest a few years back I spotted him with a gaburevolver from kyoryuger. I asked him about it and he said he knew nothing about it and just got it to look cool. He didn't even know what sentai was. You had to import that and to get it have to put in the name of the item.

    ReplyDelete
  4. He grabbed me by the pussy!

    ReplyDelete
  5. >someone horse"famous" gets into drama
    yawn

    ReplyDelete
  6. PURPLE TRANNY IS RETARDED!
    U
    R
    P
    L
    E

    T
    R
    A
    N
    N
    Y

    I
    S

    R
    E
    T
    A
    R
    D
    E
    D
    !

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Purple cocksucker.

      Delete
    2. Speaking of creepy adults who seek out incestuous pedophillic eRP from FurryMUCK...

      Trannies gotta pedo

      Delete
    3. Fucking cowardly anons to dam afraid to come off it to show their true colors

      Delete
    4. Lolz! You salty because you can't send an internet hate mob after people? As your little crybully clique is known to do. It's not cowardly, it's called being smart. Most of us aren't autistic little retards.

      Delete
    5. go back to living in that basement with that whore of a mother that gave birth to u cretin

      Delete
    6. Speaking of autistic retards, why not go visit John personally? https://kiwifarms.net/threads/purple-tinker-jessica-blank-prpltnkr-jonathan-louis-blank.30934/

      Delete
    7. yeah go fuck off she has never done wrong by me. she has always been kind and nice to our group. say what u want but i will always defend her

      Delete
    8. And that's exactly how predators like Toon and Tinker get away with their abuse. Easily manipulated pawns that either turn a blind eye to all to all the bad because they have benefited in some way, or are just too afraid of the fallout.

      Delete
    9. John/Purple Tinker doesn't have friends specifically because he views friendship as a transaction. He did a nice thing for you, so now you owe him a life debt. Say no to him just once, and you'll see how cute his hypermasculine screaming ire can be.

      Delete
    10. u dont know shit she has been a wonderful host on our cruises. i never had a problem with her. i have never been manipulated ever

      Delete
    11. Since we're on the topic I've had mixed results dealing with Purple and her Seabronies. Mostly because it was never originally her idea and merely ripped it off from scammers here in Texas. I've tried to give constructive feedback as to how to avoid 'being on the phone for 4 hours to decide the cruise' just to have her go nuts at me on Twitter.

      Oh, and the laptop she sold me had all screws stripped on the chassis so I quite haven't gotten around to replacing the cooling fan on that damn thing.

      Delete
    12. i just do the cruises cause they are fun and never have been on one before. from my honest opinion the people are hang with on them are nice people. i only see them on cruise time but they are all all around nice going people. one thing i have to say is i wish she not put herself in debt with getting va's to come along cause i would not care if we did not have one go. i am there to hangout with my friends and have fun

      Delete
    13. Without getting too derailed (and focusing on Purple in particular as I don't know any of the other goers as I've not been on one of those cruises) people similar to Purple tend to be very two faced and to a lesser extent manipulative. As long as you're on their nice side they'll always be nice otherwise you have to prepare for the worst.

      Delete
    14. Purple Tranny is definitely two-faced she's not even subtle about it. She bragged about making $150k per year, but then a week later she's hawking trinkets on eBay and begging people to 'please buy her stuff so she can buy Christmas gifts.'

      If you make $150k a year and are stupid enough that you have to hawk overpriced pony shit you scalped from Target to pay your bills, you're too stupid to be running your own bank account much less a group cruise.

      Delete
    15. Not even the group cruise but having VAs are totally unnecessary. Only reason is to boost her ego and standing within the convention community. Part of it isn't her fault. Said VAs should know better.

      I chuckle at the fact she tried to pawn a sick cat off once without paying for the treatments. Priorities man.

      Delete
  7. ngl the chick who wrote that letter is about as scummy as Toon. And stupid as shit.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Reminder that people hated Toon because of who he is. This drama was just a great excuse to exile him out of the fandom. Imagine, what if he was a Filipino? Would they still hate him? Or maybe at best, the girl would get a slap in the wrist for not being able to handle rejection.?

    People don't hate him because he is a pedophile. They hated him for breaking the law. If you're going to hate someone, hate him from your heart. Not because the government tells you to.

    -Anonymous

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. WOW HORSE NEWS COMMENT SECTION IS REALLY ABOVE EQUESTRIA DAILY SUCH THOUGHTFUL CONVERSATIONS

      Delete
    2. Thank you for contributing.

      Delete
    3. i hate toon too for what he did but those fuckholes analyst let it get this fair till it started hurting their horse fame that 15 yr old girl was alright with it till toon started to back away. i think she did this to fuck with him

      Delete
  9. How long until people finally come out about Sethisto is a pedophile, I mean we all know he's dodgy as fuck but no-one seems to be upright enough to stand up to the bulky. He bullied all these other fandom sites off the internet so it won't shock you that he did the same to young girls at pony conventions, and the likes of IDW and Hasbro turn a blind eye to it.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hey,Horse News mods it's strange you didnt screencap that comment that got its priority straight (and which btw is baseless libel so commonplace among your peers at )))4Chan((( on your Twitter account but what can we expect from channers anyways.People in glass houses shouldnt throw stone

      Delete
    2. Oh hi Seth, trying to spread more lies like you have throughout your tenure at EqD are you?

      Delete
    3. Fuck off channer piece of shit,thankfully as seen in the leaks,Hasbro dont want to see your kind around anymore :-).MLP will finally go back to who it belong since day one little girls and all you manchildrens piece of shit nerd will finally fuck off out of a fandom that was never meant for you

      Delete
    4. Child, you autistic or something? Not sure why the fuck you think any of that will happen.

      Delete
    5. What's the matter Seth? You seem terrified someone has your number and you will have to stop touching up girls as you've been found out.

      Delete
    6. Seth is no pedo, but he is an unrepentant incorrigible retard. Before infecting pone, he was known as Cynderfag, lusted for that bitch from Spyro and shitposted a furry board so bad for so many years he was put on a timeout and only allowed to shitpost on Wednesdays? It's been a while.

      Before Cynder and furry, he was a major shitposter at 4chan and his calling card was this one-winged blue-red joke dragon. Before pone, Seth had at least 10 years as an autistic scalefag.

      Delete
    7. Well we already know Shillustrious Q sucks Bobby Curnow's dick so if others are doing depraved sexual acts I wouldn't exactly be shocked.

      Delete
    8. Funny as hell knowing Toon cucked Seth. I wonder how many slutty pegasister he charmed into the sack.

      You bronies are just furries with a theme.

      Delete
    9. Exactly, but Seth seems to be untouchable among the idiots in this fanbase (so the majority of the fandom by this point).

      Delete
  10. any update if he did the right thing

    ReplyDelete
  11. Funny to see wubcake comment on this when a few years back purply roselyn accused wubcake of doing inappropriate things to her at a sleep over. Purple roselyn/wubcake arent exactly stable herself and have both been accused of lying about things and exaggerating, so take whatever they say with a grain of salt (toon is still a piece of shit though, without what either of them say).

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. What the heck are you talking about? This is about Toon, I'm pretty sure if Wubcake did anything to Purple it would have been something big, funny, cause they're good friends I seen them talking to eachother.

      Delete
    2. Moron. They're friends right this second and good ones at that.

      Delete
  12. Calling it now he's either going to jail or he's gonna kill him self. Or get killed in jail after they find out whys he's there, either way his online life is over.

    ReplyDelete
  13. Thank you for your sharing. Thanks to this article I can learn more things. Expand your knowledge and abilities. Actually the article is very practical. Thank you!
    color switch

    ReplyDelete
  14. It is heartbreaking hearing about all the people Toon used and abused and if anything good came from this leak it is his victims finally finding a voice and I can only prey they are able to now find peace.

    I find it deplorable the brony analysis community created an environment where a predator like this could was kept protected and a steady stream of victims served up on a platter for years. Even now they seem to be trying to sweep it all under the rug with this forgive and forget and business as usual attitude.

    Do they still honestly think Toon can be helped and should be forgiven AGAIN? What is wrong with these people.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. they are all shit heads who think that their fans will always forgive them. and they can do no wrong after what toon did i disowned all of them for allowing it to get this far

      Delete
    2. https://media.makeameme.org/created/bronalysis-grooming-foals.jpg

      Delete
    3. @09:13: Holy shit those OCs are horrible.

      Delete
  15. Let's see... first it was KP being a manipulative skank, then it was ToonCritic... who's next Silver Quill? Or "Dr." Wolf and his imaginary "lady-freind".

    ReplyDelete
  16. I read some articles on this site and I think your blog is really interesting and has great information. Thank you for your sharing.

    ReplyDelete
  17. It's amazing, I'm glad I read it. Super news

    ReplyDelete
  18. It is closely related to my work and has helped me grow. Thank you!

    ReplyDelete
  19. I have read this story, the content is good and attractive, thank the author

    ReplyDelete