Let's Review: Fosgitt's style by

"Art is meant to draw strong opinions, so let's take a look a very distinct style."- Silver Quill
It's bad. 

Comments (24)

  1. Wow. I've never read such a detailed review for such a small comic.
    I appreciate that you put all that time into writing this article and letting us know about each and every aspect of the story. Although I do think that you've over analyzed some parts, I think you did a pretty good job over all.

    ReplyDelete
  2. It IS complete shit. This article is quite accurate. 10/10

    ReplyDelete
  3. Also, whoever does this particular lettering (I think it's Rice? I forget) is terrible. They bold words that don't make sense being emphasized and makes it difficult to read because the voices in my head try to speak to me in the characters' voices with their inflections from the show, which don't match up at all with the emphasis in the lettering.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Rice is a terrible story writer anyway, she did that shitty Ponyville Days arc and every now and then for some reason "Ponyville Days" was called "Ponville Days" or something, going to show they didn't fix any of the errors before they released it.

      Also, why are they claiming the comics are "canon"? As far as I've seen, they're not.

      Delete
  4. EQD must be getting desperate for articles if they have to make one for an IDW artist.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. And the comments of that article are even better. It's amazing how much the true fans (autists) will suck the teat of anything branded with the MLP logo.

      Delete
    2. I dunno more than few don't like his work. At least what comments that slip through Octavia and his mod team's bullshittery at least and are not taken down.

      Delete
    3. It seems like about 60/40 for/against fosgitt in the EQD comments. There are plenty of commenters who hate his style (as they should, since it doesn't fit MLP at *all* and not to mention is just objectively ugly).

      Delete
    4. @7:38: I was referring more to people like CMC_Scootaloo that post shit like this:

      "At least those kinds of bronies. If that guy up there would continue to read the comics, he would only do it in order to bash them anyway, so the comics would have no benefits from his as a reader of them.
      Better bronies who read the comics with a fiery passion and love, then bronies who only read them because they get off at their bi-monthly fits of complaints and rages."

      Delete
    5. You mean like how CMC_Scootaloo does his annual angry fits and rages over Equestria Girls and anyone who dares to even remotely like it.

      Hypocritical asshole.

      Delete
    6. CMC_Scootaloo is not the only one, Illustrious Q, who seems to be obsessed with IDW and wants to write there, actually goes out to insult people who didn't like the comics too, and he's already been reported about twice I think.

      @20:30
      Not all autists are like that (I'm one myself yet I see how shit MLP FiM has become sometimes) but yeah, IDW has too many people sucking up to it.

      Delete
  5. I tried to imitate Fosgitt's style... success:

    https://66.media.tumblr.com/195f78e3d8ec5f61ac1d883ddc7313b3/tumblr_n5y7tzz4zY1txlpu0o1_r3_400.png

    ReplyDelete
  6. I do love how Octavia acts like a moron on the posts about IDW in the EqD comments sections. Then again you also have retards like TexasUberAlles and CMC_Scootaloo defending the damn things despite them quite obviously sucking ass for some time now.

    It's like SJWs and their bullshit, mist normal people don't fucking care and the reasonable people who do think it's shit. End of.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I wish CMC_Scootaloo would get banned. He constantly violates EQD's commenting rules, yet he somehow posts in nearly every single article on EQD, presumable since he has litearlly nothing else to do in life. But Octavia is pretty spineless... I was surprised when he did actually ban someone, but that person (i forget their username) had literally devolved to just constantly calling people retards for disagreeing... so the bar for commenting rule enforcement is pretty low.

      But whatever, EQD comments are a shithole anyways.

      Delete
    2. CMC Scootaloo? Did you know that he has a Tumblr dedicated to him:

      http://cmcscootaloser.tumblr.com/

      I also remember when he tried to contact Amnesty International when someone blocked him:

      http://cmc--scootaloo.deviantart.com/journal/Reporting-an-artist-for-abuse-of-the-block-system-602969277

      He's also a 30 year old pedophile autistic manchild, he seriosly needs an article.

      Delete
    3. Ooh ho ho that was better than my wildest dreams. I knew he was disliked but I had no idea it was that bad. Thanks for informing me, that is fantastic.

      Delete
    4. @11:24: Holy crap he's worse than I thought...

      Delete
    5. That is the tip of the iceberg when it comes to CMC_Scootaloo. He even accused CinemaQuestria of trying to profit from their streams and that was why they got a C&D. Complete horseshit as their stream suggested using an adblocker, used Ustream like most pony streams and never had any kind of Patreon it similar (unlike say, Brony Network) and the slander and lies he only perpetuated because CQ most likely sacked BolttheSuperPony for spreading the lies in the first place, and it appears the 2 were chums.

      Nasty people, the pair of them.

      Delete
    6. @23:54: Can we relabel him straight up retarded?

      Delete
    7. Relabel? When was he ever not retarded?

      Delete
    8. Oh, don't get me started on that CMC_Scootaloo shithead. He claimed I was just "being a hater" when I said I'd avoid anything with Jeremy Whitley's name on it after reading the non-canon Siege of the Crystal Empire trainwreck, and basically was spreading slander about people who didn't like the comics. Even had the nerve to report him to Disqus. He should get off the Internet, get a life and a girlfriend (I've already beaten him to that).

      He and Illustrious Q are basically IDW's asskissers, they just hurt others' feelings who don't like IDW's recent stuff.

      He unthinkingly fell in love with the shitty season 6 finale...

      He's also a 30 year old pedophile? Christ, I'm more mature than him and I'm a 21 year old autistic.

      Delete
  7. Still can't believe a convention is paying for this shit.

    ReplyDelete
  8. He is the shittiest artist next to Agnes Garbowska and Thom Zahler.

    ReplyDelete